The Best Pizza in Akron, Ohio
Akron’s pizza scene is a story of family traditions, cozy neighborhood spots, and local favorites that have stood the test of time. These aren’t cookie-cutter franchises. They’re the places where recipes are passed down, sauce is made fresh, and the same families have been running ovens for generations.
What makes it even better is the variety. In one night, you can go from a decades-old Italian institution serving molten cheese mountains to a downtown newcomer experimenting with bold flavors and late-night vibes. Whether you’re a fan of thin crusts, overloaded toppings, or something a little more refined, Akron’s pizza landscape has a slice for every taste and mood.
I’ve rounded up seven of the best local pizzerias in Akron, places that keep people coming back for cheesy comfort and crispy crusts.
Guiseppe’s Pizza
Image from Guiseppe’s Pizza Official FB Page: Link Here
Akron’s mid-century legend where deep flavor meets crispy edges
Guiseppe’s has been a local favorite for decades, and it’s easy to see why. From the moment you step inside, you notice the steady stream of regulars coming in to grab their orders and the warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels like part of the neighborhood. The dining room is simple and casual, but the real focus is on the pizza that has been drawing people back for years.
The crust has a nice balance, crisp enough around the edges but still soft in the center so it holds up under generous toppings. Their sauce is made in-house and has a rich, slightly sweet flavor with just the right amount of spice. Cheese is never an afterthought here, and you’ll find it bubbling across the whole pie. The “Jumbo Cheese” is the classic order, while “Darlene’s Favorite” adds sausage, pepperoni, and hot peppers for anyone looking for a little extra punch.
Prices are fair for the size of the pizzas, and portions are more than enough to share. Whether you order carryout for a night at home or sit down for a casual meal, the quality is consistent and satisfying.
Insider Tip: Guiseppe’s gets especially busy on Friday evenings, so call in your order ahead of time if you don’t want to wait.
Why We Picked It: Guiseppe’s is everything you want from a neighborhood pizzeria, dependable and delicious every time.
Guiseppe’s Pizza
14 E Caston Rd, Akron
Ohio, United States
1-330-644-8842
https://myguiseppes.com/
Luigi’s Restaurant
Image from Luigi’s Restaurant Official FB Page: Link Here
Akron’s iconic cheese-heavy classic since 1949
Luigi’s is the definition of an Akron landmark. Since 1949, this Main Street restaurant has been a gathering place for families, college students, and anyone craving a hearty Italian meal. The atmosphere is old-school, with wood booths, neon beer signs, and a sense that everyone inside knows they’re part of a long tradition.
The pizza is legendary for its generous portions of cheese. Order a pepperoni pizza, and you’ll find the toppings buried under a thick layer of bubbling mozzarella. The sauce has a tangy, herby flavor that balances the richness of the cheese, and the crust is sturdy without being heavy. Another standout is the Pizza Bianco, made with ricotta, provolone, and onions. It’s a pie that proves simple ingredients can make a big impression.
It’s cash only, and yes, there’s usually a line, but that’s part of the Luigi’s experience. The prices are reasonable considering the portion sizes, and leftovers almost always make it home in a box.
Insider Tip: Come late at night for the full Luigi’s experience. The dinner rush is hectic, but late hours feel more relaxed, you’ll find locals unwinding with pitchers of beer and piles of pizza. And don’t forget cash; you’ll thank yourself later when you skip the ATM run.
Why We Picked It: Luigi’s deserves its spot because it’s more than just pizza; it’s a slice of Akron’s history. Every bite feels like comfort food passed down through generations, and eating here connects you to the city itself.
Luigi’s Restaurant
105 N Main St, Akron
Ohio, United States
1-330-253-2999
https://luigisrestaurant.com/
Fiesta Pizza & Chicken
Image from Fiesta Pizza & Chicken Official Fb Page: Link Here
A neighborhood spot that delivers on both pizza and fried chicken
Fiesta Pizza & Chicken has earned its reputation by doing two comfort foods very well. Families come here because they know everyone will find something they like. The menu is split between hearty pizzas and crispy fried chicken, making it a go-to spot when cravings don’t line up.
The pizzas are generous and flavorful, with a sauce that leans savory and a crust strong enough to hold up under heavy toppings. Specialty pies often bring in a little extra spice or bold combinations that keep things interesting. Pair that with their fried chicken, which comes out golden and juicy, and you’ve got a complete meal that keeps people returning.
It’s casual, affordable, and dependable. The kind of place where you can feed a crowd without breaking the bank.
Insider Tip: Grab one of their combo deals to cover all your bases. You’ll get pizza and fried chicken at a price that feels like you’re cheating the system. It’s a lifesaver for family dinners when everyone wants something different.
Why We Picked It: Fiesta made the cut because it offers something most pizza places don’t, versatility. You can get a great pie, some of the city’s favorite fried chicken, and still walk out with money in your pocket.
Fiesta Pizza & Chicken
1860 Newton St, Akron
Ohio, United States
1-330-733-2201
http://www.fiestapizzaandchicken.com/index.html
Altieri’s Pizza
Image from Altieri’s Pizza Official FB Page: Link Here
A Kent Road classic known for thin crust and fresh toppings
Altieri’s has been part of the Akron area dining scene since 1979, and its reputation rests on consistently fresh pies. The crust is thin and crisp, especially around the edges, but it still has enough softness in the middle to carry toppings without cracking.
Their sauce is light and balanced, letting the toppings shine. Vegetables are fresh-cut, and meats have real flavor instead of filler. The result is a pizza that tastes lighter but still satisfies. Their deluxe pizza, loaded with toppings, is a customer favorite, especially when ordered with banana peppers for a little extra kick.
The atmosphere is family-friendly and welcoming, making it a good spot for both dine-in and takeout.
Insider Tip: Don’t overlook the deluxe thin crust with banana peppers. It’s a local favorite that balances tangy peppers with savory meats and fresh veggies, and it’s the pie people talk about when they leave.
Why We Picked It: Altieri’s earns its place because it’s a consistent, quality option for people who want a thinner crust without sacrificing flavor. It proves that “lighter” pizza can still leave you satisfied.
Altieri’s Pizza
3291 Kent Rd, Stow
Ohio, United States
1-330-686-6860
https://altierispizza.com/
Pierre’s Pizza & Deli
Image from Pierre’s Pizza & Deli Official FB Page: Link Here
A Kenmore favorite where pizza meets classic deli sandwiches
Pierre’s has the feel of a neighborhood institution, the kind of place where people stop by after work or before a game. The pizza is hearty and satisfying, with a crust that has good flavor and sauce that leans savory without being too heavy. Cheese and toppings are spread evenly, creating a pie that holds together well.
What makes Pierre’s different is its deli side. You can grab a hot sub, a deli sandwich, or pair one with your pizza order. It makes for a menu that works whether you’re in the mood for a full meal or just a slice and something on the side.
It’s not fancy, but it’s comfortable, affordable, and dependable, which is exactly why locals keep it in their regular rotation.
Insider Tip: Order a half pizza and half sub combo if you’re torn, it’s the best of both worlds. It’s also a clever way to share with someone who can’t settle on just one craving.
Why We Picked It: Pierre’s earned a place on this list because it’s about more than pizza. It’s a reminder that food doesn’t have to be trendy or complicated to hit the spot, and it’s built a loyal following by sticking to what works.
Pierre’s Pizza and Deli
964 Kenmore Blvd, Akron
Ohio, United States
1-330-745-7900
https://pierrespizzaanddeli.com/
Rasicci’s Pizza & Chicken
Image from Rasicci’s Pizza & Chicken Official FB Page: Link Here
Family-owned North Hill favorite with generous toppings
Rasicci’s has been serving the North Hill community for years, and it’s known for pizzas that don’t hold back. This is where you go if you like your pies loaded, with plenty of cheese, meat, and vegetables stacked on top. The crust is firm enough to carry the weight, making each slice hearty and filling.
Their menu features a mix of classic pies and specialty options that are well worth trying. The sauce is flavorful without being overpowering, giving balance to the larger portions. The atmosphere is unpretentious and focused on getting great food into your hands quickly.
For many locals, Rasicci’s is a Friday night tradition, and the line of customers proves how beloved it is.
Insider Tip: Place your order before the weekend rush. By the time you arrive, your pie will be ready, and you’ll avoid the wait that often comes with their most popular nights. It’s one of those tricks locals swear by.
Why We Picked It: Rasicci’s is here because it represents what makes neighborhood pizza so good, big flavors, big portions, and a family-run feel that makes you want to come back. It’s pizza made with the community in mind.
Rasicci’s Pizza & Chicken
513 E Cuyahoga Falls Ave, Akron
Ohio, United States
1-330-923-1999
https://www.rasiccis.com/
Dontino’s Fine Italian Cuisine
Image from Dontino’s Fine Italian Cuisine Official FB Page: Link Here
A full-service Italian restaurant where pizza gets the fine dining treatment
Dontino’s offers a different take on pizza. While many of Akron’s best spots are casual, this North Hill restaurant blends Italian entrees with pizzas that feel a little more elevated. It’s a sit-down restaurant with attentive service and a menu that includes pasta, seafood, and hearty mains, but the pizza here holds its own.
The pies are crafted with care, using high-quality cheeses and meats, and they’re presented in a way that makes them dinner-worthy. The crust is consistent and well-seasoned, the toppings balanced, and the flavors lean classic Italian rather than American-style heavy.
It’s the perfect place for a night out when you want pizza but don’t want to compromise on a nicer dining experience.
Insider Tip: Order a pizza to share alongside pasta or seafood. Splitting plates lets you experience more of Dontino’s menu in one visit, and it’s how regulars make the most of dining here.
Why We Picked It: Dontino’s is included because it shows the range of Akron’s pizza scene. Pizza doesn’t always have to be casual. Here, it’s elegant, thoughtful, and perfect for making an evening feel special.
Dontino’s Fine Italian Cuisine
555 E Cuyahoga Falls Ave, Akron
OH 44310, United States
1-330-928-9530
https://www.dontinos.com/index.htm
Final Slice
Akron’s pizza scene is full of character. Some places lean on tradition, others experiment with new flavors, but every spot on this list has built a loyal following for a reason. Whether you’re grabbing a casual Friday night pie, sitting down for a family meal, or trying something new downtown, Akron delivers.
So here’s the question: which one will you try first?
